JUDGED
A psychological legal thriller by Regina Johnston
CHAPTER ONE: APPOINTMENT
Owen Duval catches me halfway down the second-floor hallway, one file clamped under his arm and his phone in his hand. “I read everything you sent over on Parker, down to the part that came in at eleven-forty last night. Your cover note managed to sound polite and accusatory at once.”
“I said please.”
“You said it in every paragraph.” Nothing in his face tells me where any of that landed with him. “I read the children twice, then went back through the rest of it.”
That is more than he gave me by email, and it slows me down at the courtroom doors. “Where does this leave my client?”
“We’ll deal with it inside. I’m not resolving a case in a hallway.” He puts the phone away as the deputy pulls the courtroom door open, then goes up the aisle ahead of me and crosses to the State’s table. By the time I sit down his file is open and squared in front of him, and the hallway might as well not have happened.
Parker has both hands wrapped around a folder he has not opened. He starts to stand when he sees me and settles again when I take the chair beside him. “You all right?”
“Better once I’m home.”
“Then let’s get you through the morning.” His attention slides toward the State’s table, so I answer the question before he asks it. “I sent him your children’s statements again last night. I asked him to read the whole file rather than put two small kids through a hearing they should never have to carry, and he read all of it. In a minute we’ll find out what it bought us.”
He nods once and leaves the folder shut in his lap. Mine falls open on the statements I tabbed last week, back when I expected to be arguing them myself.
When the clerk calls State v. Parker for preliminary examination, we both stand. “Adeline Bennett for Mr. Parker, Your Honor.”
Duval gives his appearance for the State and stays on his feet, which tells me the answer before a word of it reaches the record. “Judge, Ms. Bennett asked us to look at this file again ahead of the hearing, specifically the statements from Mr. Parker’s children. We did. The deceased was attempting to rob Mr. Parker when he fired, and his two young children were standing next to him. On what we have, the State is not proceeding. We move to dismiss.”
Judge Celeste Herbert hears it, her expression unchanged, then looks from Duval to me. “Before testimony?”
“Yes, Your Honor. I’m not putting two small children on a witness stand to prove up a prosecution we no longer believe in.”
“Ms. Bennett, anything to add?”
“No objection. What those children said matches the rest of the investigation. My client has maintained from the first hour that he fired because he believed the man was going to hurt him and his kids.”
“Then the motion is granted, and the charge against Mr. Parker is dismissed.”
Beside me, Parker does not move. The clerk has already reached for the next matter and somebody behind us shifts along the bench. He sits with both thumbs pressed white against the unopened folder while the words go looking for somewhere to land. My hand settles on his sleeve, and the rest of the room does not need to hear the next part.
“You’re finished here. Go home and let your children watch you come through the door.”
His mouth tightens as he works the words out. “Thank you for making them look again.”
He walks out carrying the folder he never opened, taking the aisle slowly, like a man who expects to be called back. Across the room Duval closes his file and writes a line on the inside flap.
I am putting my legal pad away when Herbert calls after us. “Ms. Bennett. Mr. Duval. Stay after the docket, please. I need a few minutes with both of you in chambers.”
The rest of the docket runs a little over twenty minutes. By the time the last lawyer clears counsel table, the benches have thinned to a scatter of family waiting on somebody. We follow the judge through the side door into her chambers, where a thin folder sits apart from the stack on her desk, squared to the edge like something she has been moving around all morning.
Herbert leaves the folder untouched. “Reginald Charles Batiste filed another post-conviction application. The clerk will serve both offices before the end of business. Since I already had defense counsel and the State standing in my courtroom, I would rather you hear it from me.”
Duval takes the chair beside mine and sets his legal pad on his knee. “What is he asking the court to do?”
“This application asks the court to determine whether biological evidence collected from Rosalie Grace Dupré in 1973 still exists and, if it does, whether testing may be possible.” Herbert opens the folder and turns the caption toward us. “Batiste was convicted of her murder in 1974. The certified inventory lists fingernail material collected from the victim, and it predates DNA testing. I’m appointing Ms. Bennett for the limited purpose of finding out whether that material exists and whether its custody and condition can be established.”
Neither name means a thing to me, and I write both of them down while the judge continues.
“I’m keeping this narrow. Find out whether the material survived. If it did, establish what can be established about custody and condition. If testing becomes a real possibility, bring it back to me and the State can respond. I am not reopening a homicide today.”
Duval stops on the second page and goes over it twice before he looks up. “Is my office under any affirmative order to search?”
“No. You’ll get the same notice she does, and I expect your office to answer lawful requests. If she files something that requires more, we’ll take it up then.”
“That’s what I needed.”
The order comes across to me, and the operative paragraph is as narrow as Herbert said it was. “What do you know about whether the material exists?”
“Only what’s in the certified record, and it doesn’t answer the question. That’s why you’re being appointed.” She folds her hands and waits until she has both of us. “The case is forty-five years old. Records may be incomplete. People may remember things differently than they happened. Neither side gets to fill a gap with whatever seems likeliest, so start with what can actually be established.”
Duval closes his pad. “If Ms. Bennett sends us something, I’ll get it to the people who can answer it.”
“Thank you.” Herbert waits until Duval has finished writing, then turns to me. “Batiste receives notice of the appointment. Arrange an attorney visit at Angola. The certified material is downstairs with the clerk, and I would read it before you decide what you need from him.”
“And if the evidence is gone?”
“Then I want to know what establishes it, not what everyone assumes happened.”
“If all I can give you is where the trail stops, that’s what you get.”
“That’s the answer, and you leave the rest alone until you have facts.” She waits while I mark the margin beside the scope paragraph, then asks whether I accept. I tell her I do and that I will see Batiste as soon as the prison can get me in. At the door she adds, “Read the record before either of you starts calling people. Yes, Mr. Duval, that includes you.”
Herbert points us toward the hallway without lifting her eyes from the page, and the door closes behind us on a woman already deep in somebody else’s morning.
Duval turns for the elevators and the walk back to his own office, and I take the stairs down to the clerk’s counter, where the certified packet is waiting with the signed order on top. I check the caption and certification before any of it goes into my bag. Reginald Charles Batiste appears on the first page beneath the order, with Rosalie Grace Dupré three lines under him, and nothing in the packet says a word about who either of them was.
Outside, Poydras is so bright I squint, and the heat comes up off the concrete in a slow shove as the courthouse empties itself into traffic. The packet under my arm has gone warm at the edges by the time my phone rings and Della-Mae’s name fills the screen, so I answer at the light.
“Adeline, darling, are you out of court?”
“Just escaped. I’m going to the office before somebody finds me another hearing.”
“You sound less formal than you did this morning.”
“Herbert handed me a new appointment, so that won’t last.”
“Then I won’t keep you. I watered the porch plants and decided I am not leaving this house until the heat breaks.”
“That could be October.”
“Then I’ll be home awhile, which is no hardship at all. Call me tonight, whenever you’re done.”
She lets me go, asking nothing about what the judge gave me or whether I need help, which is a generosity most people never learn.
Beverly LaRue is one of the people I know through Della-Mae rather than through any life of my own, familiar enough that I would recognize her in a room without pretending she is family. I know the LaRue name, and I know Beverly has a son named Julian, but I have never had a relationship with him.
By the next block, the packet has warmed through my blouse and shifting it to the other arm buys me nothing. The dates on the first page have already done their arithmetic. Reginald Charles Batiste has been in prison longer than I have been alive.
My blouse is damp across the shoulders by the time I reach 650 Poydras and ride up to Suite 2117. Roxy is finishing a call with one shoe kicked half off beneath her desk, and she points at the blinking line while mouthing one minute.
“No, ma’am. Friday is Friday even if your system prefers Thursday. Send me the confirmation with the right date and I’ll stop bothering you.”
She hangs up, drops her pen beside the phone, and gives me the look she has been holding since eight o’clock. “Parker?”
“Dismissed. Duval moved, calling no testimony.”
“Somebody finally read it.” She is already reaching for the packet as I set it down. “Now tell me what Herbert gave you.”
“A homicide from 1973. Reginald Charles Batiste has been at Angola since a 1974 conviction, and the original inventory lists biological material taken from the victim.”
She goes through the order twice, the second time with her pen moving down the margin. “DNA, if any of it survived. What do you want in the request?”
“Send it to OPSO with Jaime Landry’s name on it. He supervises the property room, so he is the one who has to locate whatever exists and tell us what he can actually verify.”
She writes it down, then scans the inventory, stopping partway with a finger on one entry. “Right and left hands were collected separately, so I’m keeping them separate in the request.”
“Good. One packet can’t be allowed to answer for both.”
“And the prison?”
“Earliest attorney visit they have.”
“Before Landry answers?” When I let it sit, she lays the order flat on the desk between us. “His answer changes what you know walking into that room, El. If the samples are on a shelf somewhere, you can ask Batiste about testing with something in your hand, and if they’re gone, you know that going in.”
“I don’t want a property search writing my first hour with him. I want his account of the case before I know what survived.”
“You’re assuming less information makes a cleaner conversation.”
“I’m keeping the sources apart. His memory is one and the property room is another, and I don’t want either shaping the other until I have heard him.”
“That sounds prettier than it is.”
“Probably. I’m going anyway.”
She looks at me until I look back at her, then slides the order across the desk. “Earliest slot it is. When it turns out to be dawn, I reserve the right to complain.”
“Put the complaint in writing.”
She works the request and calls the prison as I carry the certified record into the conference room. The table gives me space to spread all of it out at once.
The opening pages state the dates plainly. Batiste was born February 17, 1952. Rosalie Dupré was killed on July 21, 1973, when he was twenty-one. His trial came the following May, a few months after he turned twenty-two.
The minute entry compresses the prosecution into a page and a half. Proceedings began on May 4, 1974, and ended the same day. The jury retired and returned twenty-eight minutes later with a second-degree murder conviction and the sentence that would keep him at Angola for the next forty-four years.
Twenty-eight minutes is barely time to eat a sandwich at counsel table. It settled the rest of a twenty-two-year-old man’s life.
Roxy comes in with her legal pad against her side and stops when she sees what I have spread across the table. “Landry has the written request, and the prison gave me tomorrow morning.”
“That fast? I expected to spend a week begging.”
“You asked for earliest, not convenient.” She notices the minute entry under my hand and tips her head to read it upside down. “What is it?”
“The whole trial took one day. The jury took twenty-eight minutes.”
She checks his date of birth against the judgment. “He’d just turned twenty-two.”
“Twenty-one when Rosalie was killed.” The name comes out of my mouth a moment ahead of my hearing it. “I want Reggie in front of me first. A property search should not start telling me which questions matter.”
Roxy catches it and lets it go, because the reception phone starts ringing again and she has never once let it ring twice.
Beneath the judgment sits the verdict poll: twelve juror names down the left side, twelve recorded votes down the right, certified by the clerk on May 4, 1974. Nine read Guilty.
The last three read Not Guilty.
I count once and stop there.
Nine to convict. Three against.
The statute in force that day confirms Louisiana did not require unanimity for the verdict entered against him. I lay the volume beside the poll and read only what I need to make sure I have the rule right.
Louisiana’s nonunanimous system came out of a constitutional design meant to reduce the power of Black jurors without excluding them from the room. I know the history. I have written it in briefs and read it in cases where the names belonged to somebody else.
Here, three people voted not guilty, and the State did not need them.
Roxy is standing at the end of the table again. I slide the poll toward her, and she works down the column without speaking.
“Nine to three.”
“That was enough.”
Her eyes stay on the final three names until the phone pulls her back toward reception.
Herbert appointed me to learn whether something taken from Rosalie Dupré’s body in 1973 still exists and, if it does, whether enough can be established about its custody and condition to bring the question back to her. That is the whole of the order.
Tomorrow I drive to Angola to meet the man who has spent forty-four years inside the result recorded on this page.
I close the statute and leave the poll open.
Keep reading
JUDGED is available now on Amazon. Buy JUDGED on Amazon